An argument against the idea of war

One of the most prevalent authors in rebutting greed vs. The same may be true of illicit drugs such as opiates, cocaine and amphetamine in developed societies.

Afghanistan[ edit ] In south central Asia, along the lawless Afghani-Pakistani border a group called the Taliban have been engaging in what could best be described as a greed based insurgency since As seen, these horizontal inequalities translated into grievances and it was these grievances that allowed extremist leaders to exploit the growing resentment to gain support and start a violent conflict.

Inthe total jail and prison population wasabout one-quarter the size it is today. The economic argument for drug legalization says: This legalize and tax argument is un-ethical and uneconomical. This meant that the Tamil population now felt economically and politically excluded and threatened.

Evidence is mounting that this policy has not only exacerbated many public health problems, such as adulterated drugs and the spread of HIV and hepatitis B and C infection among injecting drug users, but has created a much larger set of secondary harms associated with the criminal market. Authors such as Cristina Bodea and Ibrahim Elbadawi, who co-wrote the entry, "Riots, coups and civil war: Milosevic controlled the media to create grievances among the Serbian population, rally them together, and create a common enemy following NATO bombing.

Therefore, when a patient anecdotally reports a drug to have medicinal value, this must be followed by objective scientific studies. Stringent laws, spectacular police drives, vigorous prosecution, and imprisonment of addicts and peddlers have proved not only useless and enormously expensive as means of correcting this evil, but they are also unjustifiably and unbelievably cruel in their application to the unfortunate drug victims.

These tests have to be validated and reproduced if necessary in an official laboratory. And marijuana affects people of all ages: In these ways the Taliban are able to fund their insurgency and begin to fall under the characterization of a group of actors in pursuit of greed based conflict.

Extracting benefits from aid that is sent to a conflict area is also beneficial for rebel groups as there are often possibilities to raid resources sent from abroad. However, they observed that if there is a particularly high dependence on primary commodity resources, conflict risk declines as states find ways to protect their resources and deter looting.

Even though the majority of the population was Buddhist Sinhalese, with over three million people, the British people favored the Hindu Tamils, which accounted topeople. Students will present their debates to the rest of the class while role-playing both sides of the argument: Although seemingly obvious, Keen looks to demonstrate that, "the aims in a war are complex".

A second component of the Greed Model is the presence of a large diaspora funding the conflict. There is a growing misconception that some illegal drugs can be taken safely. In his book The Police and Modern Society, he stated his opinion that: This has allowed criminal, paramilitary and guerrilla groups to reap huge profits, exacerbating already serious law-and-order and political problems.

Arguments for and against drug prohibition

They argue that certain natural resources such as oil are tied to increased likelihood of conflict onset, and other natural resources such as diamonds are tied to increases in conflict duration.

Drug use is just a third of the European average while spending on drug control is three times the EU average. The United Nations Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs requires that opiates be distributed only by medical prescription, but this is impractical in many areas.

Sweden is an excellent example. Primary examples of this are weapons and drugs. As seen with Sri Lanka, these factors are more likely to drive conflict since they also provide a specific environment where charismatic leaders can pick on the grievances and create a sense of group membership that facilitates the outbreak of war.

It does so by permitting and indeed, causing the drug trade to remain a lucrative source of economic opportunity for street dealers, drug kingpins and all those willing to engage in the often violent, illicit, black market trade. A fourth function of conflict is the possible exploitation of labor.

For example, smoking one marijuana cigarette deposits about four times more tar into the lungs than a filtered tobacco cigarette. LSD has been widely researched as a therapeutic agent, and has shown effectiveness against alcoholismfrigidity and various other disorders. See, if you look at the drug war from a purely economic point of view, the role of the government is to protect the drug cartel.

Anthony Vinci makes a strong argument that, "fungible concept of power and the primary motivation of survival provide superior explanations of armed group motivation and, more broadly, the conduct of internal conflicts". He believes that conflicts are much more complex and thus should not be analyzed through simplified methods.

His definition of a "complex emergency" demonstrates this broader term and all of its various implications. Pashtun influence has a large impact on the Afghan insurgency.

Many countries have the drug problem they deserve. One of the primary characteristics of a Greed-based conflict as listed above is the ability to derive income or revenue from natural resource predation. Milosevic realized sanctions were necessary to facilitate the profitable black market transactions that were being made by those closest to him.

However, the students should add another two to four relevant questions as long as the answers can be taken directly from the primary source material. The appointment of Tamils to bureaucratic positions angered the Sinhalese population and when Great Britain granted Ceylon independence inthe Sinhalese majority aimed at correcting these horizontal inequalities perceived as disadvantageous to them.They argue that the Dutch idea of going soft on cannabis dealers, The DEA's argument also overlooks tobacco, causingUS deaths in year And, the See, if you look at the drug war from a purely economic point of view, the role of the government is to protect the drug cartel.

The first argument against the idea of just war can be found in The Concept of the Political, where Schmitt points out that killing can never be morally justifiable. He writes, Carl Schmitt's Five Arguments against the Idea of Just War.

The Mexican-American War: Arguments for and against Going to War

By Theodore Shoebat. Here is a video of me giving what I consider to be one of the best, if not the best, argument one can use against.

The Mexican-American War: Arguments for and against Going to War A Special Message Calling for a Declaration of War against Mexico, Washington, May 11, What do you believe is your opponents’ weakest argument as to declaring war or not declaring war on Mexico?

(Make sure to base your answer on evidence from the text.). The phrase "greed versus grievance" or "greed and grievance" refer to the two baseline arguments put forward by scholars of armed conflict on the causes of civil war, though the argument has been extended to other forms of war, such as violent conflict in general, rebellion and insurgency for example.

Three Arguments against War. by Jason Kuznicki. the state was not a group of people. It was not a tangible thing at all. The state was an idea—an idea of all of us doing something powerful one could have raised the very same stylized fact in an argument not against war, but against capitalism: Let us not pursue capitalism, one might.

An argument against the idea of war
Rated 0/5 based on 3 review